Ten differences between Tractatus and Philosophical Investigations

Tractatus Logico Philosophicus

  1. Written in 1918, published in 1921.
  2. Written in German, titled as “Logisch-Philosophische Abhandlung” in a journal called “Annalen der Naturphilosophie”, 14 (1921), translated to English by C. K. Ogden, titled as “Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus.”
  3. Written in formal, enumerated logical strucutre.
  4. The task of philosophy is to reveal the structure of the world by analyzing the structure of language
  5. Founded on correspondence theory of truth, linguistically “picture theory.” The world is totality of facts.
  6. Problems of philosophy arise from the bewitchment of the intellect” by language, not to be solved but dissolved through philosophy, analytically.
  7. Logic can solve problems of philosophy which are linguistic confusion.
  8. Problems can be solved with logic proving that the propositions doesn’t correspond to a reality. For this a logical language exempt from ambiguity and vagueness is required.
  9. Anything can be said in language is possible to expressed with logical propositions.
  10. The limits of world is the limits of language.

Philosophical Investigations

  1. Written in 1945, published posthumously in 1953.
  2. Written in German, titled as “Philosophische Untersuchungen”, translated to English by G. E. M. Anscombe, titled as “Philosophical Investigations”, Macmillan Publishing.
  3. Written in more informal, discursive style.
  4. The task of philosophy is exploring the idea of achieving philosophical clarity through engaging with the ambiguities and complexities of ordinary language.
  5. Founded on pragmatic theory of truth, linguistically “use theory.” The world is totality of practices.
  6. Problems of philosophy arise from the bewitchment of the intellect” by language, not to be solved but dissolved through philosophy, analytically.
  7. Logic can’t solve problems of language because it’s a dynamic game that makes sense while playing.
  8. Problems can be solved by trying to analyse the games practically and in Philosophical Investigations there are real life examples and thought experiments accordingly.
  9. Not everything is possible to express with language.
  10. The limits of the world is not rigid, limits of language games interwine and constantly change.

Leave a Reply